Small businesses can own Thanksgiving — if they’re ready

What this week means for Main Street

Thanksgiving week isn’t just busy — it’s revealing. This is the one stretch of the year when customers who normally default to big-box stores or online giants actually walk through the doors of small businesses with intention. Consumer surveys show increased preference for local shopping during the holiday season [1]. Not because of a slogan, but because the holiday forces them to slow down, shop closer to home, and look for things they can’t get from an algorithm [2].

That shift matters more this year because consumers are tired of sameness. They’ve spent months navigating generic product pages, promo overload, and impersonal transactions. By contrast, small businesses are a welcome change: fewer choices, real expertise, and goods that feel like they came from somewhere, not a fulfillment center.

This week gives small businesses a rare advantage because people are ready to buy and ready to pay attention. The businesses that use Thanksgiving weekend to actually learn about demand, refine their offer, and make buying frictionless are the ones that will carry momentum into December. The ones that treat it like “just another busy weekend” will miss the insights hiding in plain sight.

What small businesses should do about it

Steer shoppers toward margin, not staples. You can’t out-discount chains on the basics. But you can guide people to products that deliver value without killing your margins. Thanksgiving is one of the few weeks when customers are primed to buy based on story, quality, or uniqueness so lean into your natural advantage over big-box [4].

Engineer repeat business right now, when attention is high. Most holiday shoppers disappear after the season. Therefore, a smart goal isn’t just a sale, it’s a second visit. That means quick, genuine service; packaging that feels intentional; easy ways to shop again online; and a simple prompt to stay connected (QR codes, loyalty text, whatever fits your brand) [5].

Show real scarcity, not fake urgency. People know when they’re being manipulated. So, if you’re running low on something, say so authentically. When scarcity is genuine, because you actually run a small-batch or limited-inventory operation, customers act without feeling pressured, and can also feel more favorably to your business. [2].

Remove friction that sends shoppers back to big-box defaults. People love the idea of “supporting small,” but they hate inconvenience. This week, small frictions cost big dollars, like unclear hours, clunky checkout, out-of-date inventory info, missing signage, slow lines. Remove the pain points and you’ll convert sentiment into actual revenue [4].

Treat Cyber Monday as your second act. Small Business Saturday gets the PR, but Cyber Monday is where new customers often come back to buy again, this time online. Tighten your site, tune your mobile experience, prep a follow-up offer, and make sure online inventory is accurate. It’s the second bite at the apple and an invaluable way to build a customer base that can extend beyond your immediate geography [5].

Use the weekend as a demand test, not just a sales event.Thanksgiving brings in customers you don’t normally see. Watch what they gravitate toward without prompting. Those unfiltered choices tell you what has genuine pull, and what you should feature harder in December [3].

What to watch next

Customer behavior when they’re not rushed. Thanksgiving weekend’s mix of browsers and intentional buyers gives you a read on what people want when they take a little more time. That data can guide December merchandising.

Which channels produce repeat orders. Track the customers who met you in-store and returned online. It will show you whether your digital presence is supporting your brick-and-mortar, or lagging behind it.

Inventory velocity.  Use this weekend to identify fast movers, slow movers, and categories where you need either a quick reorder or a quick pivot. December margins are made by reallocating attention early.

Balance of local vs. online traffic. If local traffic shows strength this week, that may signal a holiday season where people want real-world shopping more than expected. If it doesn’t, plan to lean harder into convenience, bundles, and shipping through mid-December.

About The Art of Good

Running a small business or startup takes vision, heart, and hustle. At The Art of Good, we’re here to help you grow with clarity and confidence, using creativity, strategy, and smart tools that make a real difference.

We’re a marketing and advertising agency for the 99% - the small, mid-sized businesses and startups that are the backbone of the economy. Powered by EQ + AI, we blend human empathy and technology to focus your resources where they’ll have the biggest impact, turning limited budgets into meaningful results.

Get in touch and let’s make some good happen.

Sources

1. New York Post – consumer preference for small-business holiday shopping, Nov. 2025.

2. NielsenIQ – Thanksgiving consumer behavior trends, 2025.

3. Intuit – U.S. consumer holiday spending outlook, Oct. 2025.

4. U.S. Chamber of Commerce – Small-business holiday commerce trends, 2025.

5. National Retail Federation (NRF) – Holiday Data & Trends, 2025.